Page MenuHomePhabricator

Default source field for 'self-created' images should mention user name,
Closed, InvalidPublic

Description

Author: alex.farlie

Description:
I'm filing this here, but would appreciate it being referred if needed.

On English Wikipedia, the default source entry for self-created images appears to be something
like 'I made this image entirly' myself, when the {{tl|information}} box for an image is filled out
(possibly by [[Special:Upload]].)

However, self created images under a free-licence get moved to Wikimedia Commons,
and in the transfer process, the link between the original uploader (in the meta data)
and the 'I' in the original gets broken...

This may lead to some confusion on the part of people finding the image at Commons.

Would it be possible to adjust [[Special:Upload]] or the relevant portions of Media-wiki
to use something like ' {{User Name}} is the sole creator of this image' ? This is less
ambiguous and won't be a link that gets broken when images are moved to Commons.

Whilst this issue has arisen with English Wikipedia -> Commons it may be a potential
issue with other cross wiki-image transfers.

The alternate to this, would be to longer term look into possibly , having much closer Commons
integration in a Media Wiki extension, deprecating the current generation of bot assisted transfer
tools.

User:Sfan00_IMG


Version: unspecified
Severity: normal

Details

Reference
bz19773

Event Timeline

bzimport raised the priority of this task from to Medium.Nov 21 2014, 10:39 PM
bzimport set Reference to bz19773.
bzimport added a subscriber: Unknown Object (MLST).

Isn't this an issue with locally customized MediaWiki: messages?

This is certainly something for local wikis to do in either their messages or site JS. Marking INVALID.

By the way, add checkboxes for:

I'm uploading this photo for my
[ ]spouse
[ ]child
[ ]parent
[ ]etc.
[ ]friend
because s/he does not know how to use computers but has made this great picture, etc.