thomasV1 wrote:

this seems to be related to deferred updates

This is really a serious bug to be corrected quickly, because it affects also Special:IndexPages.

thomasV1 wrote:

this cannot be fixed quickly, because the cause is still unknown.
it is likely that the cause is deferred updates, but this is not
sure. if that cause is confirmed, then we need to find out why
the problem recently appeared; most likely a change in the way
deferred updates are applied. this change might be intended
or unintended.

It also affects http://wikisource.org/wiki/Wikisource:ProofreadPage_Statistics

I changed the severity to "major": this bug is diminishing the reliability of the proofread page extension, and demands more work from the contributors.

thomasV1 wrote:

the problem was caused by the extension incorrectly
handling deferred updates. It was fixed in r58865.
thanks to user:phe for his help.

joergens.mic wrote:

As can be seen here, the problem is not fixed!!!

http://de.wikisource.org/wiki/Index:Vom_Reichsf%C3%BCrstenstande?redirect=no The pages up to page 320 are proofread once but a lot of them are not shown so. pages following 320 are not proofread and shown correct.

I've copyed two pages (only header and footer, the bosy is removes) first the one with the fault, than a second without a fault. My problem is, that i can't see any differences between the two pages

This page is proofread once but shown as not proofreaded

'''Seite:Ficker Vom Reichsfürstenstande 163.jpg'''
This is the header of the in jedit, the only way to have a correct look at the source

<noinclude><pagequality level="3" user="Michail" />{{Seitenstatus2|[[Julius von Ficker]]|[[Vom Reichsfürstenstande]]|Vom Reichsfürstenstande}}{{BlockSatzStart}}
...
...
{{BlockSatzEnd}}{{references}}{{Zitierempfehlung|Projekt=Julius von Ficker: ''Vom Reichsfürstenstande''. Innsbruck: Verlag der Wagnerschen Buchhandlung, 1861|Seite=135}}</noinclude>

This page is proofread once and shown proofreaded
'''Seite:Ficker Vom Reichsfürstenstande 114.jpg'''

<noinclude><pagequality level="3" user="Michail" />{{Seitenstatus2|[[Julius von Ficker]]|[[Vom Reichsfürstenstande]]|Vom Reichsfürstenstande}}{{BlockSatzStart}}
...
...
{{BlockSatzEnd}}{{references}}{{Zitierempfehlung|Projekt=Julius von Ficker: ''Vom Reichsfürstenstande''. Innsbruck: Verlag der Wagnerschen Buchhandlung, 1861|Seite=114}}</noinclude>

There is no difference in the headers and footers exept for the page-ids?

I've opened the two pages with an external editor (jedit), because there is no possibilty within this extension even for administrators, to disable it for debugging or a view into the source code

Maybe it's the same fault or the next fault in this extension, I can't distinguish this. Please give us a quick response and a usefull und correct fix.

Thanks.