Innocenti.Maresin wrote:

Although 14074 marked as WONTFIX in this database, automatic rollback flagging actually worked in the past (2009–2010, say, before MW 1.17). This history http://ru.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Trine&offset=20101229999999&limit=4&action=history&uselang=en clearly demonstrates the recent revision was "automatically checked".

Any other cases? I can't repro this yet on my test wiki.

Was this actually software rollback (via [rollback]) or some JS script based rollback?

Innocenti.Maresin wrote:

We can not perform other cases, not by Yakiv_Gluck nor by other users.
I think that it was the 1.17 deployment what resulted in [[w:ru:Nokia_5230]] anomaly. An old good revision was stored before it, and vandalism and rollbacking occurred after it. So, this is probably a deployment bug, not a FlaggedRevs bug.

Ordinary action=rollback was used: http://ru.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=…&action=rollback&from=…&token=…%2B%5C

Thanks

I'll let this sit a few days before closing. I can't see why this would happen.

(In reply to comment #4)

We can not perform other cases, not by Yakiv_Gluck nor by other users.
I think that it was the 1.17 deployment what resulted in [[w:ru:Nokia_5230]]
anomaly.

Assuming this as a deployment anomaly. I can't see any likely race problems in maybeMakeEditReviewed() or autoReviewEdit() either.

Closing WMF (though that isn't the most exact status since there is an example).