Page MenuHomePhabricator

bugzilla integration with Mediawiki
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Author: saibotrash

Description:
Bugzilla is very unfriendly to use for Wikimedians (users).

You need to

  • register separately, for which you currently require a trash mail address - see [[bug:29852]] - and
  • watching bugs and
  • wikisyntax does not work.
  • Native language interface is not supported.

This hinders many users from participating, reporting and discussing bugs here. Also me until I took the time, registered a trash mail address and created an account here...

Is it possible to embed the bugzilla in Mediawiki? Then it would also be accessible simply via SUL without a separate registration. If it could be embedded on every local project even the watching would work. What about [[mw:Extension:SVNIntegration]] (found by [[:de:Benutzer:DrTrigon]])?


Version: unspecified
Severity: enhancement

Details

Reference
bz29853

Event Timeline

bzimport raised the priority of this task from to Needs Triage.Nov 21 2014, 11:27 PM
bzimport set Reference to bz29853.

(In reply to comment #0)

Bugzilla is very unfriendly to use for Wikimedians (users).

You need to

  • register separately, for which you currently require a trash mail address -

see [[bug:29852]] - and

  • watching bugs and
  • wikisyntax does not work.
  • Native language interface is not supported.

This hinders many users from participating, reporting and discussing bugs here.
Also me until I took the time, registered a trash mail address and created an
account here...

Is it possible to embed the bugzilla in Mediawiki? Then it would also be
accessible simply via SUL without a separate registration. If it could be
embedded on every local project even the watching would work. What about
[[mw:Extension:SVNIntegration]] (found by [[:de:Benutzer:DrTrigon]])?

You don't "require a trash mail address", you only "need" one if you want to remain "anonymous", for which, a lot of people don't actually care

That extension is also nothing to do with bugzilla in MW.

I think BZ supports other languages, but this is seemingly not enabled, as it seems to only list en for email language

Wiki syntax does work, look at your post, wikilinks are linked correctly. Amazing, huh? And I'm not sure why we'd need a 100% implementation of wiki syntax in a bug tracker

Having said that, SUL would be nice/a good idea.

Some of the other problems you list, are issues in BZ itself

Watching would need more code to then tie it into Special:Watchlist

  • This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 27852 ***

dr.trigon wrote:

(In reply to comment #1)

(In reply to comment #0)

Bugzilla is very unfriendly to use for Wikimedians (users).

You need to

  • register separately, for which you currently require a trash mail address -

see [[bug:29852]] - and

  • watching bugs and
  • wikisyntax does not work.
  • Native language interface is not supported.

This hinders many users from participating, reporting and discussing bugs here.
Also me until I took the time, registered a trash mail address and created an
account here...

Is it possible to embed the bugzilla in Mediawiki? Then it would also be
accessible simply via SUL without a separate registration. If it could be
embedded on every local project even the watching would work. What about
[[mw:Extension:SVNIntegration]] (found by [[:de:Benutzer:DrTrigon]])?

You don't "require a trash mail address", you only "need" one if you want to
remain "anonymous", for which, a lot of people don't actually care

That extension is also nothing to do with bugzilla in MW.

I think BZ supports other languages, but this is seemingly not enabled, as it
seems to only list en for email language

Wiki syntax does work, look at your post, wikilinks are linked correctly.
Amazing, huh? And I'm not sure why we'd need a 100% implementation of wiki
syntax in a bug tracker

Having said that, SUL would be nice/a good idea.

Some of the other problems you list, are issues in BZ itself

Watching would need more code to then tie it into Special:Watchlist

Sorry my misstake; the extensions mw:Extension:Bugzilla_Reports and mw:Extension:AuthBugzilla should have been mentioned (in place of mw:Extension:SVNIntegration) as done in bug 27001 e.g.

saibotrash wrote:

(In reply to comment #1)
Thanks for your comment, Reedy.

You don't "require a trash mail address", you only "need" one if you want to
remain "anonymous", for which, a lot of people don't actually care

I do care and the other half lot people do care, too.

That extension is also nothing to do with bugzilla in MW.

Sorry, see DrTrigon's reply.

Wiki syntax does work, look at your post, wikilinks are linked correctly.
Amazing, huh? And I'm not sure why we'd need a 100% implementation of wiki
syntax in a bug tracker

That is amazing - indeed. I thought it does not because I didn't find a preview function?!

Some of the other problems you list, are issues in BZ itself

Maybe in BZ itself - but this does not really matter for the endusers. ;)

Having SUL and watchlist and (therefore) do not have the need for a mail address would be a very great fix for having a better communication with the projects' members.

(In reply to comment #1)

if you want to
remain "anonymous", for which, a lot of people don't actually care

A lot of people in the Community want to stay anonymous. Just look at their user names. I would give you a link to [[Special:ActiveUsers]] but unfortunately this special page was removed due to Bug 41078

Wiki syntax does work

Only very limited