Author: Ianusius
Description:
the function
When you accept a page, you can give a comment about the changes which you control. This comment should be shown in the page history.
Version: unspecified
Severity: enhancement
Attached:
Description
Description
Details
Details
- Reference
- bz31554
Event Timeline
Comment Actions
(In reply to comment #0)
Created attachment 9196 [details]
the functionWhen you accept a page, you can give a comment about the changes which you
control. This comment should be shown in the page history.
This would add the the history page clutter and would need a good rationale. If it was to be done at all it would need to be collapsed by default.
Attached:
Comment Actions
Ianusius wrote:
(In reply to comment #1)
This would add the the history page clutter and would need a good rationale. If
it was to be done at all it would need to be collapsed by default.
Yes, default collapsing is a good idea. I think the comment function is really needed because so edit-wars and misunderstandings can be prevented.
Comment Actions
matthiasbecker1967 wrote:
I don't consider collapsing as a good idea. I am never ever going to understand why such a feature even was invented on MediaWiki. Especially Wikipedia is a project to inform readers and not to hide information from them.
Comment Actions
Ianusius wrote:
That is right, but we have to find a solution not to litter (?) the history. But it's right, we shouldn't use JavaScript (and not like in the new watchlist in 1.18).