Page MenuHomePhabricator

Menu items appear rearranged
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Author: shealen.clare

Description:
Three screenshots from problematic menu display

In the emulator, when the menu screen is brought up, the buttons display the wrong text and icons. Each button-location still maps to the proper action, so only the labels are incorrect.

The attached .zip file contains three screenshots:

  1. mixed_up_items
  2. Shows how the items are displayed when the bug manifests
  3. The arrangement is *not* consistent between emulator launches, but appears to change randomly.
  4. Screenshot of proper arrangement not available, but proper arrangement can be determined if the actions each button initiates actually correspond to their label.
  1. result_of_history
  2. Shows what happens when "History" is clicked.
  3. The list of pages is not the browsing history, but rather a list of saved pages. This is what the "Saved Pages" button is meant to do.
  1. result_of_more
  2. Shows how the app responds when the "More" item is tapped.
  3. Note that the label "More" is always correct.
  4. The number of items shown is far in excess of what should be shown.
  5. Again, a screenshot of proper behavior is not known, but indicators of a fix are: (1) far few items in the list, (2) no repeated elements between first level of the menu (that initially slides up) and the second level (that appears when "More" is tapped)

Version: Unspecified
Severity: normal

Attached:

Details

Reference
bz34839

Event Timeline

bzimport raised the priority of this task from to Medium.Nov 22 2014, 12:14 AM
bzimport set Reference to bz34839.
bzimport added a subscriber: Unknown Object (MLST).

pfhayes wrote:

I believe this has been fixed upstream - Shea can you confirm and mark as fixed?

shealen.clare wrote:

I can't confirm this as fixed, because I'm still having problems with this both on the emulator and on a device. The mis-mapping doesn't occur every single time I rebuild and reinstall the APK on a device/emulator, but it does happen fairly regularly.

Is anyone else in the same boat, or is it a peculiarity of my system?

pfhayes wrote:

Have you pulled the latest source and rebuilt? Yuvi said it has been fixed. I will see if I can reproduce.

shealen.clare wrote:

When you say Yuvi says it has been fixed, are we talking that fix from a few weeks back, or a more recent fix in the last pull from upstream? If you mean a newer fix, then let's close the bug now. We can always re-open it later.

pfhayes wrote:

The update was on Friday. Try and see if you can reproduce it, and then if you can't, we can close it.

shealen.clare wrote:

No longer able to reproduce the bug after most recent upstream fix.

[Merging 'Wiktionary App'&'Wikisource App' into 'Wikipedia App', see bug 41922]