Author: teju2friends
Description:
Add key combination to make letter ಹ combined with other Consonants.
Proposed key combination: ~h
Example usage:
- ಅದ್ಹೇಗೆ
ದ + ಹ = ದ್ಹ
d~ha = ದ್ಹ
Version: unspecified
Severity: normal
Author: teju2friends
Description:
Add key combination to make letter ಹ combined with other Consonants.
Proposed key combination: ~h
Example usage:
ದ + ಹ = ದ್ಹ
d~ha = ದ್ಹ
Version: unspecified
Severity: normal
I tried adding ['~h', '', 'ಹ'], as a rule and did got ~h transliterated as ಹ. Are you sure d~ha gives ದ್ಹ ? Per rule added d~h gives ದ್ಹ and d~ha gives ದ್ಹಾ
Please tell which of these is correct. If you want d~ha = ದ್ಹ then probably one more rule needs to be modified.
teju2friends wrote:
(In reply to comment #1)
Please tell which of these is correct. If you want d~ha = ದ್ಹ then probably one
more rule needs to be modified.
Some more examples:
d~h = ದ್ಹ್
d~ha = ದ್ಹ
d~he = ದ್ಹೆ
d~ho = ದ್ಹೊ
teju2friends wrote:
Also, two of key combinations which were there before Narayam implementation are missing;
W = ಔ
Y = ಐ
Please refer "ಸ್ವರಾಕ್ಷರಗಳು (Vowels)" section of help file for transliteration
http://kn.wikipedia.org/wiki/Help:ಲಿಪ್ಯಂತರ
teju2friends wrote:
(In reply to comment #1)
I tried adding ['~h', '', 'ಹ'], as a rule and did got ~h transliterated as ಹ.
Please try ಹ್ in place of ಹ( ['~h', '','ಹ್'], )
(In reply to comment #4)
(In reply to comment #1)
I tried adding ['~h', '', 'ಹ'], as a rule and did got ~h transliterated as ಹ.
Please try ಹ್ in place of ಹ( ['~h', '','ಹ್'], )
If I understand correctly, this is a ha with virama. I added it and it seems to work.
(In reply to comment #3)
Also, two of key combinations which were there before Narayam implementation
are missing;W = ಔ
Y = ಐ
Changing the bug title to reflect the additional request.
Can you please give some a sample string for unit test for W and Y along with the transliterated input?
ex:- Yeso for ಐಎಸೊ. Are there cases where these characters come in middle of a word and change the glyphs?
Also are these combination standard in kannada transliteration, as 'ai' gives ಐ and 'au' gives 'ಔ' already.
teju2friends wrote:
(In reply to comment #8)
Can you please give some a sample string for unit test for W and Y along with
the transliterated input?
nAkYdu = ನಾಕೈದು
ಗೌತಮ್ = gWtam
teju2friends wrote:
(In reply to comment #8)
Also,
W = ಔ
Y = ಐ
WShadhi = ಔಷಧಿ
Ydu = ಐದು
kY = ಕೈ
kW = ಕೌ
(In reply to comment #9)
(In reply to comment #8)
Can you please give some a sample string for unit test for W and Y along with
the transliterated input?nAkYdu = ನಾಕೈದು
ಗೌತಮ್ = gWtam
Isn't it good enough to write "nAkaidu" and "gautam"? It produces the same results and it is implemented already.
Are these W and Y letters based on some other transliteration standard or just the old typing script in the Kannada Wikipedia?
Added nAkaidu , auShadhi and gautam also to the test cases. See . https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/9740
Alternate key combinations are fine. But since they are not obvious( in phonetical way) to the users, it must be documented well. https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Help:Extension:Narayam/Kannada/Transliteration need some help - First of all it should be in English, and the kannada version should be translated from English version. And it should be updated to reflect this change.
teju2friends wrote:
(In reply to comment #11)
Isn't it good enough to write "nAkaidu" and "gautam"? It produces the same
results and it is implemented already.
W and Y are added to achieve minimum key stroke. This was there before Narayam implementation.
Are these W and Y letters based on some other transliteration standard
No
or just the old typing script in the Kannada Wikipedia?
Yes. Old script was fine tuned to balance between phonetical & minimum keys.
(In reply to comment #12)
Added nAkaidu , auShadhi and gautam also to the test cases. See .
https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/9740
Please add these too,
W = ಔ
Y = ಐ
Ydu = ಐದು
kY = ಕೈ
kW = ಕೌ
WShadhi = ಔಷಧಿ
nAkYdu = ನಾಕೈದು
ಗೌತಮ್ = gWtam
Alternate key combinations are fine. But since they are not obvious( in
phonetical way) to the users, it must be documented well.
W (ಔ) and Y (ಐ) were already there in documentation. I will add about ~h.
(In reply to comment #13)
Merged. Thanks for the contribution!
Thanks! ~h is working as expected. Please update W and Y too.
(In reply to comment #14)
(In reply to comment #13)
Merged. Thanks for the contribution!
Thanks! ~h is working as expected. Please update W and Y too.
~h is working because it was deployed weeks back in 1.20wmf4. The fix for W and Y just got merged and will be deployed in the next deployment window. Mostly next Tuesday
teju2friends wrote:
(In reply to comment #15)
~h is working because it was deployed weeks back in 1.20wmf4. The fix for W and
Y just got merged and will be deployed in the next deployment window. Mostly
next Tuesday
Thanks!