Author: kht1992
Description:
Please delete [[들:]] and [[들토:]] aliases which are for {{NS:100}} (Portal) and {{NS:101}} (Portal talk) per local discussion on [[:ko:위키백과토론:단축#들머리 이름공간 단축이 필요할까요?]]. There was no consensus to add this aliases, and we are not using this aliases rarely.
Version: wmf-deployment
Severity: enhancement
jyl4you wrote:
This request hasn't been confirmed by the Kowiki community. The discussion about deleting this alias is ongoing now.
kht1992 wrote:
(In reply to comment #1)
This request hasn't been confirmed by the Kowiki community. The discussion
about deleting this alias is ongoing now.
You're only opposing without any proper reason in the community. Please do not be disruptive.
Unfortunately I cannot really understand the discussion. It does not seem like a clear consensus, though.
kht1992 wrote:
(In reply to comment #3)
Unfortunately I cannot really understand the discussion. It does not seem
like
a clear consensus, though.
It looks like there's no consensus, but I(관인생략) and DFSM are supporting, Jytim is Support/Neutral, and only NuvieK is opposing only because "there exists portal aliases". So I decided this is no need to discuss because it looks like disruptive editing/discussion.
"_I_ decided there is no need to discuss though somebody is against it" does not convince me personally.
I agree with This, that and the other: This request would welcome clearer consensus, created in the thread on the local wiki (NOT in this Bugzilla). Maybe get more people involved to get a wider set of arguments/opinions? :-/
(In reply to comment #4)
(In reply to comment #3)
Unfortunately I cannot really understand the discussion. It does not seem
like
a clear consensus, though.It looks like there's no consensus, but I(관인생략) and DFSM are supporting,
Jytim
is Support/Neutral, and only NuvieK is opposing only because "there exists
portal aliases". So I decided this is no need to discuss because it looks
like
disruptive editing/discussion.
DO NOT IGNORE ME! I oppose also in this suggestion
jytim wrote:
Yeah, thanks for closing the request. Plus, I'm Jytim, and I apposed deleting two aliases.
(In reply to comment #8)
Yeah, thanks for closing the request. Plus, I'm Jytim, and I apposed deleting
two aliases.
I suggest resolving this bug as WONTFIX for now, so when Hotae's opinion - deleting alias - has consensus then he can REOPEN it.
(In reply to comment #9)
(In reply to comment #8)
Yeah, thanks for closing the request. Plus, I'm Jytim, and I apposed deleting
two aliases.
- This request is not closed.
- Bugzilla doesn't matter whether you appose or not. All discussion should
be
discussed onwiki.
(appose=>oppose)
There isn't enough community consensus to implement this change, and the on-wiki discussion seems to have stopped, therefore marking this bug as RESOLVED INVALID. Please feel free to reopen once community agreement is found.