Steps to reproduce:
1.Insert an image in a page
2.Change the size of the image by going to Custom tab
3.Click on "Apply Changes"
4.Now again open the media settings dialog and switch to default tab
Observed Result:
Previously as soon as user switched to default tab, it used to set the text fields to default size, but now its keeping the custom size values.
Version: unspecified
Severity: normal
Change 147219 had a related patch set uploaded by Mooeypoo:
Make the image model work without a node
I can't manage to reproduce this in master or in beta labs.
When a new image is inserted, the default behavior is that it has 'default' size. If the user goes to the size widget and just clicks the 'custom' button, it will transform the existing (default) values to custom values (so, the values are the same as the default, but they are literally expressed).
So the values are the same because the user didn't change them, but the difference is whether the image is default or limited in size (despite the fact both sizes are functionally the same)
For instance, for the image "Chef's knife grip.jpg" in beta labs:
Clicking "Custom" size will result in this wikitext:
[[File:Chef's knife grip.jpg|thumb|200x200px]]
Clicking "Default" size will result in this wikitext:
[[File:Chef's knife grip.jpg|thumb]]
That's the expected result. Is something else happening? I can't reproduce a bug.
I cant reproduce it now , the problem was after changing the custom size value, when i was clicking on default tab , it was not changing the size values into default on the size value fields.But now it seems like doing that.
This is again happening in production for this image:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Black_sandbox.JPG
Go to this page: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:RYasmeen_(WMF)/sandbox&oldid=619869934
Go to the Media settings>Advanced Settings for this image.Switch to default tab.
Observe that, the size values are still showing 22x17 which should be 220x165 as soon as I switch to Default tab.
If you click on Apply Changes and reopen this dialog , still you will see its showing 22x17 instead of 220x165.
If you Save the page and then reopen the page and the media settings dialog only then you will see the size value got changed to 220x165
Change 149217 had a related patch set uploaded by Mooeypoo:
Make the image model persistent
Change 158395 had a related patch set uploaded by Mooeypoo:
Set default dimensions based on original dimensions
Change 158395 merged by jenkins-bot:
Set default dimensions based on original dimensions